{"schema_version":"papers/paper-detail-v1","title":"When Reviews Disagree: Fine-Grained Contradiction Analysis in Scientific Peer Reviews","surface":"papers","opportunity_kernel":{"paper_id":"84e740df-8fbe-49a7-9336-b374334354d7","title":"When Reviews Disagree: Fine-Grained Contradiction Analysis in Scientific Peer Reviews","authors":["Sandeep Kumar","Yash Kamdar","Abid Hossain","Bharti Kumari","Tanik Saikh","Asif Ekbal"],"arxiv_id":"2605.10171v1","doi":null,"published_at":"2026-05-11T08:20:58.000Z","score_object":{"overall":{"value":8,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.85,"confidence_reason":"Backfilled from persisted papers.viability_score.","model_version":"phase0-web-fallback-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-12T20:15:46.673Z","fresh_until":"2026-06-11T20:15:46.673Z","is_stale":false,"source_count":1,"missingness":[]},"technical":{"value":0,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.15,"confidence_reason":"No canonical technical score row was available yet; marked low confidence.","model_version":"phase0-web-fallback-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-12T20:15:46.673Z","fresh_until":"2026-05-26T20:15:46.673Z","is_stale":true,"source_count":0,"missingness":["paper_score_objects.technical"]},"commercial":{"value":4,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.7,"confidence_reason":"Backfilled from persisted commercial_flags and repo availability.","model_version":"phase0-web-fallback-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-12T20:15:46.673Z","fresh_until":"2026-06-11T20:15:46.673Z","is_stale":false,"source_count":1,"missingness":[]},"market":{"value":0,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.15,"confidence_reason":"No canonical market score row was available yet; marked low confidence.","model_version":"phase0-web-fallback-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-12T20:15:46.673Z","fresh_until":"2026-05-26T20:15:46.673Z","is_stale":true,"source_count":0,"missingness":["paper_score_objects.market"]},"team":{"value":0,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.15,"confidence_reason":"No canonical team score row was available yet; marked low confidence.","model_version":"phase0-web-fallback-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-12T20:15:46.673Z","fresh_until":"2026-05-26T20:15:46.673Z","is_stale":true,"source_count":0,"missingness":["paper_score_objects.team"]},"methodology":{"value":0,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.15,"confidence_reason":"No canonical methodology score row was available yet; marked low confidence.","model_version":"phase0-web-fallback-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-12T20:15:46.673Z","fresh_until":"2026-06-11T20:15:46.673Z","is_stale":false,"source_count":0,"missingness":["paper_score_objects.methodology"]}},"evidence_receipt":{"freshness":"fresh","proof_status":"unverified","repo_status":"missing","references_count":0,"source_count":0,"coverage":0,"missingness":["paper_evidence_receipts.references_count","paper_evidence_receipts.coverage"],"unresolved_unknowns":["Canonical evidence receipt has not been materialized yet."],"last_verification_at":"2026-05-12T20:15:46.673Z"},"lineage_hash":"1780af2a05e8456f15566a71fbe529d47f6223306d55d48b970c903ebca462b3"},"distribution":null,"replication_evidence":[],"author_dna":[]}