{"schema_version":"papers/paper-detail-v1","title":"Stop Automating Peer Review Without Rigorous Evaluation","surface":"papers","opportunity_kernel":{"paper_id":"7b4b1fa2-a43f-41ee-886b-bc798f5770c7","title":"Stop Automating Peer Review Without Rigorous Evaluation","authors":["Joachim Baumann","Jiaxin Pei","Sanmi Koyejo","Dirk Hovy"],"arxiv_id":"2605.03202v1","doi":null,"published_at":"2026-05-04T22:41:04.000Z","score_object":{"overall":{"value":4,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.85,"confidence_reason":"Backfilled from persisted papers.viability_score.","model_version":"phase0-backfill-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-06T20:10:16.692Z","fresh_until":"2026-06-05T20:10:16.692Z","is_stale":false,"source_count":1,"missingness":[]},"technical":{"value":1.4,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.55,"confidence_reason":"Backfilled from paper_extraction_scorecards.reconstruction_score.","model_version":"phase0-backfill-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-06T20:11:12.389Z","fresh_until":"2026-05-20T20:11:12.389Z","is_stale":true,"source_count":1,"missingness":["reproducibility_results.reproducibility_score","deployability_scores.score"]},"commercial":{"value":4,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.75,"confidence_reason":"Backfilled from persisted commercial_flags and repo availability.","model_version":"phase0-backfill-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-06T20:10:16.692Z","fresh_until":"2026-06-05T20:10:16.692Z","is_stale":false,"source_count":1,"missingness":[]},"market":{"value":2,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.45,"confidence_reason":"Heuristic market score materialized from paper metadata, repo availability, and deployability.","model_version":"phase0-backfill-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-06T20:27:14.697Z","fresh_until":"2026-05-20T20:27:14.697Z","is_stale":true,"source_count":1,"missingness":[]},"team":{"value":3.6,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.28,"confidence_reason":"Heuristic fallback from paper author count.","model_version":"phase0-backfill-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-06T20:10:16.692Z","fresh_until":"2026-05-20T20:10:16.692Z","is_stale":true,"source_count":1,"missingness":["paper_author_affiliations"]},"methodology":{"value":3.9,"scale":"0-10","confidence":0.82,"confidence_reason":"Backfilled from paper_extraction_scorecards.total_score.","model_version":"phase0-backfill-v1","pipeline_version":"phase0-kernel-v1","computed_at":"2026-05-06T20:11:12.389Z","fresh_until":"2026-06-05T20:11:12.389Z","is_stale":false,"source_count":2,"missingness":[]}},"evidence_receipt":{"freshness":"stale","proof_status":"unverified","repo_status":"missing","references_count":0,"source_count":3,"coverage":0.5,"missingness":["repo_url","references","proof_status"],"unresolved_unknowns":["proof verification has not been recorded yet"],"last_verification_at":"2026-05-06T20:27:14.697Z"},"lineage_hash":"67e501250ec6f30c4516cc8cce6332e77c0815effaa1db7f954eeee761a47c46"},"distribution":null,"replication_evidence":[],"author_dna":[]}